|
Haaretz, September 11 - Seven years later, By Tom Segev - Seven years ago today, it looked as though the world would never again be what it was before the attack on the World Trade Center. At the south end of Manhattan I, too, had trouble breathing, and the choking dust carried with it a yellowish, nauseating threat...
On the first anniversary, everyone tried to define the historical
significance of the 9/11 attacks, and to formulate profound insights
about the social changes they had brought about. It was a pretentious
and foolish attempt.
Everyone also spoke about the patriotism that had swept America, a
clear expression of insecurity and a conservative attempt to hold on to
the values of the past. …
Many assumed at the time that mayor Rudy Giuliani would be the next
president of the United States, and had that really happened, it would
have been possible to say the attack on the Twin Towers really did make
history. The real story is that the shock of the attack didn't last
long, and the glory of the leader-savior enjoyed by Giuliani evaporated
quite quickly.
"September 11th," as people now say in almost every language, also
offered a good opening for a historical discussion on the decline of
America. The U.S. has lost its status as the sole superpower, and the
recent economic crisis has brought about a situation whereby most
Americans do not believe today that their children will live a better
life than they have. This is ostensibly the most profound expression of
the loss of personal security that everyone attributed to the attack;
after all, the need to remove one's shoes during the security check
before boarding a plane has not really changed the American dream.
Nor is America sinking, of course. As opposed to the muscular atrophy
that it broadcasts occasionally, during the past year, it has
demonstrated social vitality and an amazing ability for renewal, with
almost half of the American public apparently having decided that for
the first time they are ready for a black president. The conservative
patriotism that seized them seven years ago and that often includes
racist elements, did not destroy their ability to advance toward their
national dream. …
Seven years after that day in September, the attack is too distant for
tears, too near for understanding. Therefore, it may be no coincidence
that the American media are returning this week to the survivors of the
attack and the bereaved, asking them what they feel and what has
happened to them since then, as though it were their private disaster.
We can learn from that - it's easier to enter the culture of memory
than the history books.
TO SEARCH OR NOT TO SEARCH ?
Spiegel, September 9 - Large Hadron Collider - The Controversial Search for the God Particle - Will the Large Hadron Collider, set to be fired up on Wednesday, bring
about the end of the world? Most physicists say no -- but they are
hoping for clues as to how the universe began.
Talk about a public relations problem. Imagine spending years sinking
vast quantities of money, time and ambition into an intricately complex
project only to face accusations just before the project's debut that
you might accidentally bring about the end of the world.
This, essentially, is the PR issue facing the Large Hadron Collider
(LHC) as scientists on Wednesday plan to send the first beam of protons
around the 27-kilometer (17-mile) long loop buried deep below ground
not far from Geneva, Switzerland. Physicists say that the €6.4 billion
($9.2 billion) project -- the lion's share of which came from European
countries -- may provide unique new insights into how our universe was
formed, the existence of "dark matter" and even the possible reality of
a number of new dimensions.
Critics, though, many of whom have found a powerful platform on the
Internet, fear that by smashing protons against each other at
99.9999991 percent of the speed of light, scientists could create tiny
black holes which could eventually grow to the point that they swallow
up the Earth.
The European Organization for Nuclear Research -- known by its French
acronym CERN -- has spent considerable energy discounting such fears.
An international team of scientists published yet another assessment of
the particle accelerator's safety over the weekend in the Journal of
Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics -- to go with a number of other
safety evaluations conducted by the project.
"The LHC is safe, and any suggestion that it might present a risk is pure fiction," said Robert Aymar, who heads CERN.
Still, the project has been swamped by e-mails from those concerned
that scientists may be biting off more than they can chew. Videos on
YouTube show what it might look like were a black hole, starting below
the ground outside of Geneva, to swallow up the Earth. Skeptics in the
United States filed suit in a US District Court in Hawaii in an attempt
to block the project. A similar effort was mounted by a German
scientist who brought suit at the European Court of Human Rights --
though the case was tossed out at the very end of August.
One Nobel prize-winning physicist associated with the project, Frank
Wilczek from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, has even
received death threats connected with the start of the LHC. "I have
received threats by both e-mail and by telephone," Wilczek told SPIEGEL
ONLINE. "I'm trying not to let it bother me -- with some success."
Even if scientists say they are confident that switching on the LHC
won't bring the world to a sudden end, some of them are hoping to find
evidence of dimensions in excess of the four we are currently aware of.
Because the LHC is the most powerful and most precise particle
accelerator ever built, many see it as the best opportunity yet to find
proof for the veracity of "string theory."
String theory is a mathematical construct that many believe might
explain away inconsistencies between Albert Einstein's General Theory
of Relativity and quantum mechanics -- a major focus in theoretical
physics for much of the last century. The highly complex models used in
string theory point to the possible existence of up to 11 dimensions
and also make predictions about the existence of some as-yet unobserved
sub-atomic particles. Should the LHC be able to find some of those
particles, a much touted theory of physics would have its first kernel
of proof.
But string theory is just one idea being investigated by the thousands
of scientists from more than 80 countries who will be running,
analyzing and evaluating the experiments at the Large Hadron Collider.
Many also hope to find the elusive "Higgs boson," a theoretical
particle named after the Scottish physicist Peter Higgs. He came up
with a theory in 1964 to help explain what gives mass to matter, thus
making the universe possible. Higgs pointed to a particle that has so
far never been observed. By creating conditions similar to those that
existed at the birth of our universe, the so-called "Big Bang,"
scientists hope to be able to find Higgs boson, also known as the "God
Particle."
Others will be looking for all manner of sub-atomic particles and
anti-particles, the origins of dark energy and the make-up of dark
matter.
Almost just as interesting, though, is the massive computer network
CERN has set up to evaluate the prodigious quantities of data the LHC
will produce. Called the LHC Grid, the network will encompass some
60,000 computers around the world in order to leverage enough computer
power to go through the 15 petabytes of information LHC experiments
will produce each year.
"You can think of each experiment as a giant digital camera with around
150 million pixels taking snapshots 600 million times a second," Ian
Bird, who heads up the LHC Grid project, told the Associated Press.
Within those billions of pixels -- collected by a multitude of
ultra-sensitive sensors within the tunnel -- might be a few that show
minimal evidence of a new sub-atomic particle.
Still, despite all the hype and the hope, scientists truly don't know
exactly what they'll find in this grandest of all scientific
experiments. "What I would like to see is the unexpected," Gerardus
t'Hooft, a physicist at the University of Michigan, told Reuters.
Perhaps, he says, the LHC "will show us things we didn't know existed."
But for those expecting the end of the world, the wait will continue
for another few weeks. The Large Hadron Collider won't actually begin
bashing protons against each other until later this autumn.
Haaretz, September 10 - Israeli scientists join experiment to break open 'Big Bang' - It is afternoon in the control room of the Atlas particle detector, the biggest and most complex system of its kind. Prof. Giora Minkenberg of
the Weizmann Institute is examining the tracks of a few muons 100 deep
meters in the ground, which were picked up by the apparatus. Minkenberg
points out the path of the muons, elementary particles that bear a
negative charge, a heavy version of an electron.
"These are plain muons," he explains. "They are from the cosmic
radiation reaching the earth. They were picked up in our experiment
just by chance."
But if scientists identify a Higgs Boson (or "God particle") by the
muons it breaks up into, this will be the key to proving, or
disproving, the standard theory guiding nuclear physics.
International physicists at the vast underground complex near Geneva
inaugurated a 20-year project on Wednesday that will try to reenact the
Big Bang, in an attempt to explain the origins of the universe and how
it came to harbor life.
In a giant machine called the Large Hadron Collider, or LHC, at the
CERN research center straddling the Franco-Swiss border just outside
Geneva, scientists plan to smash particles together to create a
small-scale reenactment of the event that kicked off the cosmos.
The LHC will use giant magnets housed in cathedral-size caverns to fire
beams of energy particles around a 27-km tunnel where they will collide
at close to the speed of light. Computers will record what happens each
time, and the vast store of material gathered will be analyzed by some
10,000 scientists around the globe for clues on what came next.
Scientists at CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research,
will pursue concepts such as "dark matter," "dark energy," extra
dimensions and, most of all, the Higgs Boson "God particle" believed to
have made it all possible.
"The LHC was conceived to radically change our vision of the universe,"
said CERN's French Director-General Robert Aymar. "Whatever discoveries
it brings, mankind's understanding of our world's origins will be
greatly enriched."
Minkenberg, 61, divides his time between CERN and Weizmann. He has been
conducting experiments with CERN for over 20 years. Now he spends his
time running from building to building in last-minute preparations for
the launch, and smokes his pipe between the meetings. He is the head of
the Israeli team, consisting of over 50 scientists, including students.
Other members of the Israeli team include Prof. Ehud Duchovni and Prof.
Eilam Gross from Weizmann, along with others from Tel Aviv University
and the Technion.
CERN scientists have been at pains to deny suggestions by some critics
that the experiment could create tiny black holes of intense gravity
that could suck in the entire planet.
Cosmologists say the Big Bang occurred some 15 billion years ago when
an unimaginably dense and hot object the size of a small coin exploded
in what was then a void, spewed out matter that expanded rapidly to
create stars, planets and eventually life on Earth.
But the 10 billion Swiss franc ($9 billion) CERN project, begins with a
relatively simple procedure: pumping a particle beam around the
underground tunnel.
Technicians will first attempt to push the beam in one direction round
the tightly-sealed collider, some 100 meters underground. Once they
have done that - and CERN officials say there is no guarantee they will
be successful in the initial stages - they will project a beam in the
other direction.
And then, perhaps in the coming weeks, they will pump beams in both
directions and smash the particles together, initially at low
intensity. At the end of the year, they will move on to produce tiny
collisions that will recreate the heat and energy of the Big Bang, the
reigning theory on the origin of the universe.
The detectors will monitor the billions of particles that will emerge
from the collisions, capturing on computer the way they come together,
fly apart or just simply dissolve.
It is in these conditions that scientists hope to fairly quickly find
the Higgs Boson, named after Scottish scientist Peter Higgs who first
proposed it in 1964 as the answer to the mystery of how matter gains
mass.
Without mass, the stars and planets in the universe could never have
taken shape in the aeons after the Big Bang, and life could never have
begun - on Earth or, if it exists as many scientists believe, on other
planets.
But the experiment is not without detractors. Certain Web sites on the
Internet, which CERN created 20 years ago as a means of passing
particle research results to scientists around the globe, have been
promoted claims that the LHC will create black holes that will suck in
the planet. "Nonsense," say the CERN and leading international
scientists.
"The LHC is safe, and any suggestion that it might present a risk is pure fiction," said Aymar.
Herald Tribune, September 10 - Physicists run first particles through CERN collider, by Dennis Overbye - Batavia, Illinois: Science rode a beam of subatomic particles and a river of Champagne into the future Wednesday.
After 14 years of labor, scientists at the CERN laboratory outside
Geneva successfully activated the Large Hadron Collider, the world's
largest, most powerful particle collider and, at $8 billion, the most
expensive scientific experiment to date.
At 10:27 a.m. in Geneva, scientists sent the beam of protons around the
collider's racetrack, which is 17 miles, or 27 kilometers, long and
runs deep beneath the Swiss-French border, and then sent another beam
through again.
"It's a fantastic moment," said Lyn Evans, who has been the project
director of the collider since its inception. "We can now look forward
to a new era of understanding about the origins and evolution of the
universe."
Eventually, the collider is expected to accelerate protons to energies
of seven trillion electron volts and then smash them together,
recreating conditions in the primordial fireball only a trillionth of a
second after the Big Bang. Scientists hope the machine will be a sort
of Hubble Space Telescope of inner space, allowing them to detect new
subatomic particles and forces of nature.
An ocean away from Geneva, the collider's activation was watched with
bittersweet excitement here in Batavia at the Fermi National
Accelerator Laboratory, or Fermilab, which until that moment had the
reigning particle collider.
Several dozen physicists, students and onlookers gathered to watch the
dawn of a new generation in high-energy physics, applauding each
milestone of the night as the beam was slowly wrestled into shape at
CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research.
Many of them, including the lab's director, Pier Oddone, were wearing
pajamas or bathrobes or even nightcaps bearing Fermilab patches on them.
Oddone lauded the new machine as the result of "two and a half decades
of dreams to open up this
huge new territory in the exploration of the
natural world."
Roger Aymar, CERN's director, called the new collider a "discovery
machine." The buzz was worldwide. Gordon Kane, of the University of
Michigan called the collider "a why machine," in a posting on the blog
"Cosmic Variance."
Others, worried about speculation that a black hole could emerge from
the proton collisions, have called it a doomsday machine, to the dismay
of CERN physicists who can point to a variety of studies and reports
that say that this fear is nothing but science fiction.
But Boaz Klima, a Fermilab particle physicist, said that the
speculation had nevertheless helped create buzz and excitement about
particle physics. "Bad publicity is still publicity," he said. "This is
something that people can talk to their neighbors about."
The only thing physicists agree on is that they don't know what will
happen when the collisions reach the energies just after the Big Bang.
"That there are many theories means we don't have a clue," Oddone said. "That's what makes it so exciting."
Many physicists hope to materialize a hypothetical particle called the
Higgs boson, which according to theory endows other particles with
mass. They also hope to identify the nature of the mysterious invisible
dark matter that makes up 25 percent of the universe and provides the
scaffolding for galaxies. Some dream of revealing new dimensions of
space-time.
But those discoveries are in the future. If the new collider is a car,
then what physicists did Wednesday was turn on an engine that will now
sit and warm up for a couple of months before anybody drives it
anywhere. The first real collisions, at an energy of five trillion
electron volts, will happen later this autumn.
Nevertheless, the symbolism of the moment was not lost on the experts and nonexperts gathered in Batavia.
At 2 a.m. local time, Herman White, a physicist here, and master of
ceremonies for the night, took the stage to announce the night's
schedule. For at least the next few hours, he said, "we are still the
highest-energy accelerator in the world," to wild applause.
In an interview earlier that day, Oddone called it a "bittersweet moment."
Once upon a time, the United States ruled particle physics. For the
last two decades, Fermilab's Tevatron, which hurls protons and their
mirror opposites, anti-protons, together at energies of a trillion
electron volts, was the world's largest particle machine.
By the end of the year, when the CERN collider has revved up to five
trillion electron volts, the Fermilab machine will be a distant second.
Electron volts are the currency of choice in physics for both mass and
energy. The more you have, the closer and hotter you can punch back in
time toward the Big Bang.
In 1993, the U.S. Congress canceled plans for an even bigger collider
and more powerful machine, the Superconducting Supercollider, after its
cost ballooned to $11 billion. That collider, its former director Roy
Schwitters of the University of Texas in Austin said recently, would
have been in operation around 2001.
Schwitters said that U.S. particle physics - the search for the most
fundamental rules and constituents of nature - had never really
recovered from the loss of the supercollider. "One nonrenewable
resource is a person's time and good years," he said, adding that many
young people had left the field for astrophysics or cosmology.
Oddone, Fermilab's director, said the uncertainties of steady
congressional funding made the situation at Fermilab and physics in
general in the United States "suspenseful."
CERN, on the other hand, is an organization of 20 countries, whose
budget is determined by treaty and thus stable. The year after the
supercollider was killed, CERN decided to go ahead with its own
collider.
Fermilab and the United States, which eventually contributed $531
million for the collider, have not exactly been shut out. Oddone said
that Americans constitute about a quarter of the scientists who have
built the four giant detectors that sit at points around the racetrack
to collect and analyze the debris from the primordial fireballs.
In fact, a remote-control room for monitoring one of those experiments,
known poetically as the Compact Muon Solenoid, was built at Fermilab,
just off the lobby of the main building here.
"The mood is great at this place," he said, noting that the Tevatron
was humming productively and accumulating data at a much more rapid
pace than the CERN collider would initially produce. There is even
still a chance that Tevatron could find the sacred Higgs boson before
the new hadron collider, which is bound to have a slow start.
Another target of physicists is a principle called supersymmetry, which
predicts, among other things, that there is a vast population of new
particle species left over from the Big Bang and waiting to be
discovered, one of which could be the long-sought dark matter.
"It would be a very rich life if supersymmetry is found," Oddone said.
"It would amount to permanent employment for physicists for decades.
"The truly surprising thing is if we don't see anything."
By the time festivities started, at 2 a.m. Chicago time, outside and
inside the control room for the solenoid detector, Fermilab had been
festooned with balloons and the accelerator was already half an hour
late. The superconducting magnets that guide the protons around on
their path have to be cooled to 1.9 degrees Kelvin, about 3.5 degrees
Fahrenheit above absolute zero, and one of the eight sectors of the
underground ring was too warm, so scientists had to wait to cool it
back down.
Then Evans, the collider project director, outlined the plan for the
evening: sending a bunch of protons clockwise farther and farther
around the collider until they made it all the way. He confessed to not
knowing how long it would take, noting that for a previous CERN
accelerator it had taken 12 hours. "I hope this will go much faster,"
he said.
Twenty minutes later, when the displays in the control room showed that
the beam had made it to its first stopping point, the crowd applauded.
Twenty minutes after that, the physicists erupted in cheers when their
consoles showed that the muon solenoid had detected collisions between
the beam and stray gas molecules in the otherwise vacuum beam pipe.
Their detector was alive and working.
Finally, at 3:27 Chicago time, the display showed that the protons had
made it all the way around to another big detector named Atlas, whose
members quickly confirmed that their experiment had also seen
collisions.
At Fermilab, they broke out the Champagne. Oddone congratulated his European colleagues.
"We have all worked together and brought this machine to life," he
said. "We're so excited about sending a beam around. Wait until we
start having collisions and doing physics."
CULTURE
September 11 - Israel Diamond Museum displays ancient jewelry - New exhibition of rare and ancient jewelry excavated in archeological
sites throughout Israel - "Apples of Gold in Pictures of Silver" - pays
tribute to Israel's rich tradition of jewelry design.
The Harry Oppenheimer Israel Diamond Museum, located within the Israeli
Diamond Industry complex, will open an exhibition of rare and ancient
jewelry excavated in archeological sites throughout Israel on September
12, 2008.
The exhibition reveals gold jewelry that has never before
been seen, much of which dates from Biblical times and even earlier.
The jewels, some of which are set with precious stones, enable a rare
glimpse into the lifestyle and culture of the ancient Israelites, and
attest to the Land of Israel's unique position as a cultural and
commercial crossroad of the ancient world. All of the items have been
lent to the Diamond Museum courtesy of the Israel Antiquities Authority.
The exhibition also reveals a great deal about the creation of ancient
jewelry - the methods, the craftsmen, the influences of other ancient
civilizations and the role jewelry played in the religion and culture
of the times. Over 100 pieces from the huge collections of the Israel
Antiquities Authority and the Hecht Museum were individually chosen by
curator Yehuda Kassif to shed light on this subject.
Many of the pieces on display seem to have been created today - and
might appear in the collections of leading contemporary jewelry
designers. However, the exhibition brings us back to the days of the
Bible, when golden balls used in intricate jewelry designs were known
as "apples". The exhibition takes its name from the Book of Proverbs,
chapter 25, verse 11: "A word fitly spoken is like apples of gold in
pictures of silver."
Eli Avidar, Managing Director of the Israel Diamond Institute Group of
Companies as well as the Israel Diamond Museum, said "This exhibition
is The Israeli Diamond Industry's tribute to the ancient jewelry
tradition of the Land of Israel. It is a fitting way to connect our
past and present, especially during Israel's 60th anniversary." He
added that the Israeli Diamond Industry is poised to expand its
activity into jewelry manufacturing, with many Israeli diamantaires now
designing and producing their own lines of diamond jewelry. "Our
ancient roots include a rich jewelry-making tradition. This exhibition
is a unique opportunity to explore this tradition, which forms the
basis for our contemporary jewelry creations. I invite jewelry
designers to visit and to take inspiration from these timeless pieces,"
he said.
The Harry Oppenheimer Israel Diamond Museum was reopened this year
after undergoing a major renovation, making it the most modern diamond
museum in the world. In addition to a permanent display that utilizes
the most modern technologies to showcase the fascinating journey of the
diamond from the depths of the earth to the finished jewel, the museum
holds changing exhibitions featuring jewelry from around the world.
This is the first exhibition of ancient jewelry to be held in the
diamond complex.
Shmuel Schnitzer, Chairman of the Israel Diamond Museum, said: "This
exhibition, with its journey through the corridors of time, is another
jewel in the crown of the renovated museum that serves as the showcase
of the international world of diamonds - a world in which the Israeli
industry plays such a central role."
|